The Real Herbert Hoover Record

March 28, 2011 11:18 pm 2 comments

Herbert Hoover, 1931, Oil on canvas by Douglas ChandorWith the after-effects of the so-called “Great Recession” still lingering — unemployment is still at close to 9%, even after the “stimulus” spending of nearly a trillion dollars (spending that was supposedly necessary to keep the unemployment rate below 8%), and economic growth is still sluggish — and the landslide election victories for Republicans in November 2010, there is now real debate around cutting government spending at the local, state, and federal level.

Predictably, such calls for fiscal discipline bring the inevitable references to President Herbert Hoover and his response to the stock market crash of 1929 and his response to what would become the Great Depression.  According to the conventional narrative, it was Hoover’s supposed laissez faire inaction that was the catalyst for the economic malaise that consumed the United States for the next decade and a half.  As is often the case, however, the conventional narrative departs from the truth:  Hoover, far from the caricature, was not a free market, limited government advocate; rather, he fit in with the progressives of his day, seeing government as a tool for shaping a better world.  He sought a much more aggressive, progressive, activist government than had been the hallmark of his predecessor Calvin Coolidge.

When Hoover took office, the top marginal income tax rate was 25%.  The top bracket started at an annual salary of $100,000 — quite a sum at that time.  Hoover’s response to the building economic crisis was to raise taxes.  Only on the “rich” of course.  President Hoover dispatched his Treasury Secretary, Andrew Mellon, to Congress to lobby for an increase in the top tax rate from 25% to 63% on those making over $1,000,000 per year.  He was successful:  Congress granted his request, and the tax increase was enacted.  Taxes were also increased on estates (today known as the “death tax” by opponents) and corporations.  Secretary Mellon, who was reluctant to request the increase and ultimately lamented it, was later chastised as one of the greedy capitalists, “economic royalists” in Roosevelt’s vernacular, responsible for the depression.

President Hoover also sought to shore up the economy by protecting American businesses, particularly farmers, from overseas competition.  He pressed Congress to pass the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act, which raised tariffs on nearly every sector to historically high rates.  As predicted in a letter written to President Hoover by 1,028 economists urging him to veto the act, enactment of the new tariffs spurred reprisals from other countries — a “trade war” — resulting in a worldwide slowdown in trade and commerce that further exacerbated the economic malady.

So the Hoover approach to a “credit crunch”, bank closures, and a crisis on Wall Street was to raise taxes on corporations and “the rich”, and to increase tariffs on imported goods and services.  But that wasn’t all:  Hoover also greatly increased federal government intrusiveness and expense.  As detailed by economist Don Boudreaux of George Mason University, “spending rose significantly during Hoover’s term in the White House…The overall increase in real per-capita spending from 1928 to 1932 was a whopping 53.5 percent.”   In her book The Forgotten Man, Amity Schlaes also details how President Hoover called business and industry leaders to the White House to harangue them on matters economic.

President Hoover’s tax increases, protectionism, and expansion of the size, scope, intrusiveness, and expense of the federal government did nothing to halt the steady economic decline of the early years of the Great Depression.  Of course, that didn’t stop Hoover’s successor, Franklin Roosevelt, from doubling down on the Hoover approach — FDR simply raised taxes even further and spent even more in a desperate attempt to fight off economic decline.  The result was the worst economic period in the history of the United States:  rampant joblessness persisted until the country mobilized to fight World War II, and prosperity did not return until the war was ended and the governmental shackles were loosened.

That is the real Herbert Hoover record:  tax increases, spending initiatives, and trade interference.  It is modern-day budget-busting big spenders — not budget-cutting restrainers of government — that carry on his legacy.

Leave a Reply


Other News

  • Christian Persecution World Russia Declares ‘Holy War’ On Islamic State

    Russia Declares ‘Holy War’ On Islamic State

    The Orthodox Christian Church, which is reclaiming its traditional role in post-Soviet Russia, has just described its government’s fight against the Islamic State and other jihadi groups in Syria as a “holy war.”

    According to Vsevolod Chaplin, head of the Church’s Public Affairs Department,

    The fight with terrorism is a holy battle and today our country is perhaps the most active force in the world fighting it. The Russian Federation has made a responsible decision on the use of armed forces to defend the People of Syria from the sorrows caused by the arbitrariness of terrorists. Christians are suffering in the region with the kidnapping of clerics and the destruction of churches. Muslims are suffering no less.

    This is not a pretext to justify intervention in Syria.

    Read more →
  • 2nd Amendment Faith Oregon Shooting – When Tragedy Happens Let’s Focus On The Cause And Not The Tools Used

    Oregon Shooting – When Tragedy Happens Let’s Focus On The Cause And Not The Tools Used

    While the blood was still dripping from those martyrs who, in front of an evil man armed with a gun, asked them if they were Christians and those strong in the faith said they were. He shot them in the head. While those who were lost or weak said nothing he spared their lives and shot them in their legs.

    Barrack Hussein Obama angrily ran to the cameras to use this opportunity to say that guns being in the hands of the law-abiding Americans is the problem, and we need to restrict the 2nd amendment to spare the lives of “we the people.”

    This is nuts; guns do not kill people, people kill people! You can test this fact in your own home right now. (Do not worry no one will get hurt).

    Read more →
  • 2nd Amendment Faith Gun Free Zones Are Killing Zones

    Gun Free Zones Are Killing Zones

    How did you feel when you heard of the shootings in Oregon this week? Was the first thing that came to your mind the thought that if we only had stricter gun control legislation, this kind of tragedy could have been prevented?

    If you listened to idiotic liberals, like President Barack “Insane” Obama, you might believe that. It is my contention that liberalism is a mental disorder based on the rejection of God and His principles, and extreme irresponsibility.

    Read more →
  • National Where’s the Beef, in Republican candidates, in 2015?

    Where’s the Beef, in Republican candidates, in 2015?

    What type of Republican Leader do you want in 2015?

    As we look at elections coming up quickly in 2015, as well as the very important 2016 election cycle, what type of “Republican” leaders do you want to shape the future of your county and country?

    Do you ever wonder why it is that the current crop of Republicans are not declaring, at every media interview, “These ills have been brought to you by the Democrat Party!” when speaking of Obamacare, the hordes of immigrants being allowed to destroy our country, the Iranian nuclear treaty, the “Black Lives Matter” racial division rhetoric, the attack on the defense of marriage, the 94 million Americans not currently in the work force,

    Read more →
  • National Child protection services Sentences Baby To Death ON 9/11/2015

    Child protection services Sentences Baby To Death ON 9/11/2015

    Child protection services should be self-explanatory based on the simplicity of its name. But they are doing exactly opposite of their name in many places. Wynne, Arkansas is one such place.

    A baby has been sentenced to death and will be executed on Friday, September 11, 2015 and Arkansas Department of HUMAN SERVICES (DHS) – Division of Children and Family Services- Central Office will facilitate the delivery of the baby’s 10-year-old to the abortion clinic.

    On August 29, 2015 20-year-old Justin Smith was arrested and charged with three counts of rape and one count of endangering the welfare of a minor. His “alleged” victim is a 10-year-old.

    Read more →